Skip to content
  • Home
  • Whisky Top 10
  • Tasting Notes
  • About Thijs
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Whisky Top 10
  • Tasting Notes
  • About Thijs
  • Contact
logo
glen garioch 15 years old sherry cask matured

Glen Garioch 15 Years Sherry Cask Matured (2019)

14 February 2020 0 comments Article Glen Garioch, Highlands, Scotland, Tasting Notes

As pointed out in this excellent blog post on Whisky Science, the origins of sulphury notes in whisky are hard to pinpoint. Often wine or sherry casks are singled out as the culprits, supposedly tainted by the use of sulphur candles, but there’s no real evidence to suggest excess use of these candles in the sherry industry.

Also, there’s good and bad sulphur in whisky. I sometimes find sulphur notes in whisky that actually sort of enhance the flavour palette. Sulphur comes in different forms, and some compounds make for meaty aromas or grapefruit even. That doesn’t sound too bad, right?

Jim Murray has been ridiculed for a lot of things actually, but one that has always stood out to me was his critique of sulphured whiskies. He spent a large part of the introduction of his 2013 Whisky Bible warning about the dangers of sulphur. ‘We’re facing crisis time’, is how he described it.

I don’t know if I would go that far, but there are certainly examples of sulphured whiskies that I found quite baffling. It is beyond me how some of these withstood the scrutiny of a master blender or even a nosing panel. And then again, simple economics prove me wrong most of the time.

The best example is probably this monstruous 20yo Deanston, but today’s subject also fits the bill. The Glen Garioch 15 Years Sherry Cask is undoubtedly sulphured — and yet very popular. It scores well on Whiskybase too. Must be me then…

Glen Garioch 15 Years Sherry Cask Matured (53.7%, OB, 2019)

Nose: Intense with an undeniable amount of sulphur. Hints of forest fruits, cassis and bitter chocolate. Whiffs of pepper and nutmeg, as well as a hint of soy sauce.
Taste: More sulphur, what a shame. Pretty dry and somewhat sour with spicy notes of nutmeg and black pepper. A touch of tobacco laves, as well as marmelade.
Finish: Medium in length. More of the same.

Score: 75

This falls squarely in the category of ‘Wouldn’t recommend this, but still drinkable’. The sulphur is too present for me, distracting from what otherwise would be a good whisky.

Photo: Whiskybase

Thijs Klaverstijn Kingairloch 3
Thijs Klaverstijn

Thijs is a spirits writer and accredited liquorist from The Netherlands. He runs the blog Words of Whisky and contributes to a number of Dutch and international publications.

Tags: 15yo, glen garioch, highlands, sherry cask matured

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Tumblr

Most popular posts

  • Glendronach cask (flickr ti yab) GlenDronach Is A Lot Older Than The Label Says
  • secret orkney 1999 20yo michiel wigman Secret Orkney 1999 20 Years (Michiel Wigman)
  • ben nevis 2015 5yo adelphi whisky import nederland 10715 Ben Nevis 2015 5 Years (Adelphi)
  • glenallachie 1995 24yo the duchess 23 Glenallachie 1995 24 Years (The Duchess)
  • benromach 21yo 2020 Benromach 21 Years (2020)

Recent blog posts

  • Upcoming: Blind Tasting Competition
  • Sexism & Misogyny in our Whisky Community
  • Monologue: Waterford’s Mark Reynier on Biodynamics & Terroir
  • Why The Whiskybase Gathering Should Be On Your Bucket List
  • Visiting Ballindalloch Distillery: Tradition & Patience in Speyside

Copyright Words of Whisky 2018